Guides

Do We Guarantee Planning Approval?

There is one common question we hear a lot here at Formed Architects, that typically comes from homeowners and developers: “Do you guarantee planning approval?”

The truth is that we simply cannot. Planning has too many variables and sometimes, as much as it seems counterintuitive, we actually aim for a refusal to maximise what is actually possible to do for your project.

In this video post, I’ll walk through exactly why a guaranteed planning approval isn’t necessarily going to be in your best interest. I’ll also go over how we approach planning applications to get the best outcomes for you.

Transcription:

Right, today I wanted to talk a little bit about whether or not your architect should be guaranteeing planning. And this stems from a question that we often get asked by potential customers, homeowners and developers alike, as to whether or not we guarantee planning. And the real answer is we can’t.

There’s just way too many variables in place to guarantee planning and partly because sometimes we actually want a refusal. So let me kind of break that down a little bit. If we were to guarantee planning, that means we’re probably erring on the side of caution, which means we’re probably not pushing the boundaries for you and not maximising the parameters of what may or may not be possible.

Equally if you’re looking for sort of guaranteed planning the reality is the person assessing that is always slightly different.

We’ve had instances same local authority, one application will go through and the second one they will say our guidelines say no and it’s almost like a computer says no process and then we’re kind of wondering and we put the case to them that we’ve had approval in the same local authority for the same thing further down the road and they said well that case is different and so because it’s so subjective and we sit in a position where we can’t guarantee planning.

So, what can you do to kind of enhance your success rate of getting planning first time round if that is critical for you.

And in that instance, we probably say actually it’s worth going down a pre app route. So pre app is essentially a council giving you some initial advice in relation to your application that is kind of informal.

So, nobody knows that you’ve made that application, that pre application to get the advice. But critically you’re in a position where you will have something in writing from the council to say whether or not they support it.

Unfortunately, that advice is not binding. So that in itself doesn’t guarantee planning. And we have had instances where we’ve had a really positive pre app where then when it’s put in front of the next officer that’s assessing it effectively you know goes back to computer says no.

So, there is no sort of clear-cut guarantee with planning. So where does that leave us? As I said there are some instances where we want a refusal in place and to give you an example of that, we had an instance where we were developing a couple of houses and at the back of the garden we wanted to put in some large outbuildings.

Now under permitted development you’re allowed sort of 30 square metres for these outbuildings, but the gardens were significantly bigger than that and we wanted a larger outbuilding.

The council were going to refuse it on the premise, even under full planning that their guidelines said only 30 square metres, which in this particular garden would have meant that, you know, we were significantly smaller than the potential would allow. So, we waited for the refusal and then put the case to appeal and subsequently won an appeal.

And so, the actual outbuilding size is per property, we’re closer to 60 square metres. So, you can understand in some instances it’s useful to get a refusal in place.
Another reason why we don’t guarantee planning. And the last point is if you are considering sort of engaging a practice that is guaranteeing planning, always ask yourself how are they guaranteeing and some people will advertise 100 % planning track record.

I’d be surprised if that is the case. That normally means that they withdraw the application before any potential chance of refusal to maintain that record. And that necessarily isn’t positive because then you don’t have the feedback from the officer that you would then get if the planning application had been refused.

Sometimes when an application is refused, the feedback is just as critical to be able to then get the application through the second time round. And some things can be small nuances about heights and sizes and sort of impact on what they consider to be impact on the amenity or potential additional information that they felt was missing the first time around.

If you withdraw the application, you’re less likely to get that sort of, you know, confirmation of why, the reasons for refusal, and so you aren’t able to process it for a guaranteed second time win.

So, there are a couple of variables there as to why we don’t guarantee planning. But essentially, I think if you are looking for that kind of guaranteed route, perhaps you want to ask yourself why and what is it that is restricting you from actually taking the risk to make planning applications.

Generally, from our perspective, we run a sort of 90%-95 % track record with planning approvals first time round. So, as I said on occasion, we will want to refuse it. On occasion we will push the risk boundary a little bit to be able to maximise what is possible.

And so that yeah, too many variables to guarantee planning and although some people promise sort of 100 % track record, it likely means that your application is being withdrawn before the council can refuse so that they can maintain their track record. But that doesn’t necessarily mean that put you in a better place.

Essential Insights:

  • We are unable to guarantee planning approval due to variables and subjective decisions that are part of the process.
  • Having pre-application advice can increase your overall chances of success, but it’s not guaranteed and doesn’t necessarily mean that you will gain approval.
  • In some projects, a refusal can actually be a good thing. It allows us to appeal and secure a better outcome for your project.
  • Taking an overly cautious approach to planning could actually limit the potential of your project. This is why we, as architects, will sometimes push the boundaries of the application, even at the risk of refusal.
  • Any practices that claim a 100% perfect success rate will often withdraw applications before refusal. This is problematic because it can actually prevent valuable feedback needed for successful resubmission.

While the idea of guaranteed planning approval might sound appealing, it often comes at the cost of limiting your project’s potential.

By embracing a more flexible approach, we can explore greater possibilities, even if it involves navigating the complexities of planning objections and appeals.

Ultimately, our goal is to achieve the best outcome for your project, not just an easy approval, and that sometimes means taking calculated risks to maximise what’s possible.

Discuss Your Project With Us

Blog Post Form
What is your comfortable budget for this project?
Our starting level of engagement at the feasibility stage is £1500, and can increase based on the size and scope of your project. Does this fit within your budget?

Maximum file size: 8.39MB

Share