
Ever wondered when it would be best to use a small practice as opposed to a large one? What are the benefits of using a large practice for your small home extension?
Not sure what the pros and cons are of using a small or large practice?
This article will give you an honest insight to find out these answers and the pros and cons of using a small architects’ practice versus a large firm.
Firstly, a small architectural firm generally provides all the same services that a large practice provides, and where they can’t will have small consultant teams to support. Since a small practice has fewer staff to perform all the services and duties, you are likely to have a singular point of contact within the architectural team, this will hopefully allow you to develop a better rapport with the design team and result in a more considered approach to your extension that suits your need.
Whereas in a larger practice, there are more people assigned to various responsibilities of your project and very rarely would you meet the principal architect, which could result in a breakdown of communication and maybe situations where you might find cross overs that don’t align with your brief.
Small practices are often more varied on a day-to-day basis, therefore, have the capacity to work on more projects within a shorter timeframe because they are smaller in nature, and can therefore prioritise and manage to suit customer needs.
Whereas, a larger practice, generally work on commercial and higher budget projects (possibly, to assist in covering the extensive overheads and expenses that comes with running a larger practice), which could in turn leave you waiting for a considerable amount of time for your project to be delivered due to staffing restrictions and management towards smaller projects, essentially the smaller projects get lost in the company’s workflows.
Often, smaller practices are geared up to supporting those that have not undertaken a home extension, or those working with a small or limited budget who don’t have the slightest idea on where to begin for their projects to be realised.
At a smaller practice you can get more guidance and support from seniors (holding your hand throughout the whole process), and chances of building a more intimate working relationship for customers to learn and understand as the project develops with each stage.
Within a larger practice, although there are more resources to support your project, due to higher associated overheads you may find that you get less hand holding and building of a personal relationship, it may pass multiple points of contact and continuity of delivery of your vision may need to be reiterated.
That said, sometimes having multiple eyes working on the project can lead to a diversity in thought that can lead to a richer project as opposed to a sole practitioner type practice where you may be limited by the architect’s previous experience or style.
With a larger practice you might have to be prepared to have conversations with various team members throughout the duration of your project – as it may well be that the project needed to be divided amongst the practices’ staff members (juniors assisting senior more skilled) in order to deliver it successfully due to the project’s size and budget brief; leaving no real opportunity to develop an intimate working equation with a single point of contact during the life of the project.
One of the pros of using a large practice over a smaller practice is that they tend to generally have a team of consultants in-house (planning consultants, structural engineers, quantity surveyors, party wall specialists etc) who can work holistically to address any queries, ensuring things run smoothly and remain on track.
However, this does come with a slight con, as timeframe deliverables for the separate services among the different consultants must coincide with one another for the project to run smoothly.
Furthermore, as many of the consultant services are all in house, these services would have been priced into the practices’ overall service package – this may help manage the administration of paying for services, although can leave you with less price flexibility had you gone out to the market to obtain quotes for the other consultant services (which isn’t to say that a larger practice couldn’t facilitate this, although you may want to factor in any additional costs from the practice to obtain these quotes or your time to do so, they may also add a mark up on consultant costs so you should be clear about this from the outset.
Larger practices also tend to work with larger consultants and so you can have similar issues with the handling of your project with the associated consultants.
A smaller practice would work in much the same way – but go out to the market to obtain quotes for the relevant required services for a given project and coordinated by seniors so the project can run as smoothly as possible. Allowing the homeowner to have a choice and make savings on the service consultants they use.
Large practices are likely to work in multiple sectors and have different teams focusing on certain sectors. This brings some cross sector expertise to the delivery of your project which can be missing with a smaller practice that may predominantly work on smaller homeowner projects and extensions like the one you are doing.
The smaller architectural practice may also be better set up to manage your project through the build with suitably skilled builders to deliver the build. You may find that a larger practice will not offer services for the stages beyond the design and statutory approvals and if dealing with builders makes you feel nervous this may not be for you.
This in itself could have its advantages – are you looking for a more bespoke and considered final result with each detail and junction thought through?
This may need additional work at the outset and the eye of the lead architect during constructions stages may be critical in achieving this – check if you are going with a larger practice that they can offer this as often it may not make commercial sense for them to get stuck working out all the small nitty gritty details – even if they are important to you.
Check whether delivery of your home extension is just a numbers game for the practice – this would apply to both small and large practice – are you happy to be just another customer with an extension to be churned out with little attention, or do you want a more tailored service – will the larger practice with it’s commercial considerations be able to deliver this in a cost effective and timely manner without you feeling like you are in a conveyor belt?
Equally, some smaller practices may work in a similar way; churning out extension projects with little consideration for the end user so if this is important to you, it would be useful to understand the cost that this comes at.
To summarise:
Working with a small architectural practice has the following pros:
- Close collaboration with the lead architect, who will likely be heavily involved in the design and management of your project
- More flexibility and ability to make changes to the design as needed
- More personalised service and attention
- Potential for more unique and creative design solutions
Working with a small architectural practice also has some cons:
- Limited resources and expertise compared to larger firms
- Less experience with large or complex projects
- Less ability to handle multiple projects at once
- May have less established reputation or portfolio – although if it is a home extension you are looking for check their portfolio specifically caters for this.
Working with a large architectural practice has the following pros:
- Access to a wide range of resources and expertise
- More experience with large or complex projects
- Ability to handle multiple projects at once
- Established reputation and portfolio although they may not do so many home extensions
Working with a large architectural practice also has some cons:
- Less personalised service and attention
- Less flexibility and ability to make changes to the design
- Less close collaboration with the lead architect
- Design solutions may be less unique or creative
To conclude, ultimately, the choice is yours. Choosing to go with a small/medium sized practice or a larger practice is dependent on your own personal needs for your extension project (time, budget, level of service required, guided assistance – if it’s your first time, communication etc.) of which both can cater for.
You must be clear on your objective, timeframes and budgets and ensure whether you go for a large or small practice that they will cater to suit.
You may want to find out more by watching our video on things to ask an architect when you first meet them.



